Itinerantdaughter's Blog

… that I didn’t write.

When I was young and ripe with angst, I was in group therapy with a girl even younger and more full of angst than myself (the latter being debatable.)  She was a Manhattanite born and bred, but not a silver spoon, Brearly-educated Manhattanite, rather the product of an ill-fated marriage (mom became a lesbian) whose friends hung out in the gritty East Village and had impromptu threesomes.  She was a girl who started smoking at fourteen and wore dark eyeliner and had moody photos of pale waifs half-submerged in bathtubs cut out from magazines pasted all over her wall.  She was a chubby, unibrowed child who became this dark, lovely teenager with impossibly tiny wrists and a slow tone that could make you swoon.  And this was her favorite short story:

The Most Beautiful Woman in Town, by Charles Bukowski

Cass was the youngest and most beautiful of 5 sisters. Cass was the most beautiful girl in town. 1/2 Indian with a supple and strange body, a snake-like and fiery body with eyes to go with it. Cass was fluid moving fire. She was like a spirit stuck into a form that would not hold her. Her hair was black and long and silken and whirled about as did her body. Her spirit was either very high or very low. There was no in between for Cass. Some said she was crazy. The dull ones said that. The dull ones would never understand Cass. To the men she was simply a sex machine and they didn’t care whether she was crazy or not. And Cass danced and flirted, kissed the men, but except for an instance or two, when it came time to make it with Cass, Cass had somehow slipped away, eluded the men.

Her sisters accused her of misusing her beauty, of not using her mind enough, but Cass had mind and spirit; she painted, she danced, she sang, she made things of clay, and when people were hurt either in the spirit or the flesh, Cass felt a deep grieving for them. Her mind was simply different; her mind was simply not practical. Her sisters were jealous of her because she attracted their men, and they were angry because they felt she didn’t make the best use of them. She had a habit of being kind to the uglier ones; the so-called handsome men revolted her- “No guts,” she said, “no zap. They are riding on their perfect little earlobes and well- shaped nostrils…all surface and no insides…” She had a temper that came close to insanity, she had a temper that some call insanity. Her father had died of alcohol and her mother had run off leaving the girls alone. The girls went to a relative who placed them in a convent. The convent had been an unhappy place, more for Cass than the sisters. The girls were jealous of Cass and Cass fought most of them. She had razor marks all along her left arm from defending herself in two fights. There was also a permanent scar along the left cheek but the scar rather than lessening her beauty only seemed to highlight it. I met her at the West End Bar several nights after her release from the convent. Being youngest, she was the last of the sisters to be released. She simply came in and sat next to me. I was probably the ugliest man in town and this might have had something to do with it.

“Drink?” I asked.

“Sure, why not?”

I don’t suppose there was anything unusual in our conversation that night, it was simply in the feeling Cass gave. She had chosen me and it was as simple as that. No pressure. She liked her drinks and had a great number of them. She didn’t seem quite of age but they served he anyhow. Perhaps she had forged i.d., I don’t know. Anyhow, each time she came back from the restroom and sat down next to me, I did feel some pride. She was not only the most beautiful woman in town but also one of the most beautiful I had ever seen. I placed my arm about her waist and kissed her once.

“Do you think I’m pretty?” she asked.

“Yes, of course, but there’s something else… there’s more than your looks…”

“People are always accusing me of being pretty. Do you really think I’m pretty?”

“Pretty isn’t the word, it hardly does you fair.”

Cass reached into her handbag. I thought she was reaching for her handkerchief. She came out with a long hatpin. Before I could stop her she had run this long hatpin through her nose, sideways, just above the nostrils. I felt disgust and horror. She looked at me and laughed, “Now do you think me pretty? What do you think now, man?” I pulled the hatpin out and held my handkerchief over the bleeding. Several people, including the bartender, had seen the act. The bartender came down:

“Look,” he said to Cass, “you act up again and you’re out. We don’t need your dramatics here.”

“Oh, fuck you, man!” she said.

“Better keep her straight,” the bartender said to me.

“She’ll be all right,” I said.

“It’s my nose, I can do what I want with my nose.”

“No,” I said, “it hurts me.”

“You mean it hurts you when I stick a pin in my nose?”

“Yes, it does, I mean it.”

“All right, I won’t do it again. Cheer up.”

She kissed me, rather grinning through the kiss and holding the handkerchief to her nose. We left for my place at closing time. I had some beer and we sat there talking. It was then that I got the perception of her as a person full of kindness and caring. She gave herself away without knowing it. At the same time she would leap back into areas of wildness and incoherence. Schitzi. A beautiful and spiritual schitzi. Perhaps some man, something, would ruin her forever. I hoped that it wouldn’t be me. We went to bed and after I turned out the lights Cass asked me,

“When do you want it? Now or in the morning?”

“In the morning,” I said and turned my back.

In the morning I got up and made a couple of coffees, brought her one in bed. She laughed.

“You’re the first man who has turned it down at night.”

“It’s o.k.,” I said, “we needn’t do it at all.”

“No, wait, I want to now. Let me freshen up a bit.”

Cass went into the bathroom. She came out shortly, looking quite wonderful, her long black hair glistening, her eyes and lips glistening, her glistening… She displayed her body calmly, as a good thing. She got under the sheet.

“Come on, lover man.”

I got in. She kissed with abandon but without haste. I let my hands run over her body, through her hair. I mounted. It was hot, and tight. I began to stroke slowly, wanting to make it last. Her eyes looked directly into mine.

“What’s your name?” I asked.

“What the hell difference does it make?” she asked.

I laughed and went on ahead. Afterwards she dressed and I drove her back to the bar but she was difficult to forget. I wasn’t working and I slept until 2 p.m. then got up and read the paper. I was in the bathtub when she came in with a large leaf- an elephant ear.

“I knew you’d be in the bathtub,” she said, “so I brought you something to cover that thing with, nature boy.”

She threw the elephant leaf down on me in the bathtub.

“How did you know I’d be in the tub?”

“I knew.”

Almost every day Cass arrived when I was in the tub. The times were different but she seldom missed, and there was the elephant leaf. And then we’d make love. One or two nights she phoned and I had to bail her out of jail for drunkenness and fighting.

“These sons of bitches,” she said, “just because they buy you a few drinks they think they can get into your pants.”

“Once you accept a drink you create your own trouble.”

“I thought they were interested in me, not just my body.”

“I’m interested in you and your body. I doubt, though, that most men can see beyond your body.”

I left town for 6 months, bummed around, came back. I had never forgotten Cass, but we’d had some type of argument and I felt like moving anyhow, and when I got back i figured she’d be gone, but I had been sitting in the West End Bar about 30 minutes when she walked in and sat down next to me.

“Well, bastard, I see you’ve come back.”

I ordered her a drink. Then I looked at her. She had on a high- necked dress. I had never seen her in one of those. And under each eye, driven in, were 2 pins with glass heads. All you could see were the heads of the pins, but the pins were driven down into her face.

“God damn you, still trying to destroy your beauty, eh?”

“No, it’s the fad, you fool.”

“You’re crazy.”

“I’ve missed you,” she said.

“Is there anybody else?”

“No there isn’t anybody else. Just you. But I’m hustling. It costs ten bucks. But you get it free.”

“Pull those pins out.”

“No, it’s the fad.”

“It’s making me very unhappy.”

“Are you sure?”

“Hell yes, I’m sure.”

Cass slowly pulled the pins out and put them back in her purse.

“Why do you haggle your beauty?” I asked. “Why don’t you just live with it?”

“Because people think it’s all I have. Beauty is nothing, beauty won’t stay. You don’t know how lucky you are to be ugly, because if people like you you know it’s for something else.”

“O.k.,” I said, “I’m lucky.”

“I don’t mean you’re ugly. People just think you’re ugly. You have a fascinating face.”

“Thanks.”

We had another drink.

“What are you doing?” she asked.

“Nothing. I can’t get on to anything. No interest.”

“Me neither. If you were a woman you could hustle.”

“I don’t think I could ever make contact with that many strangers, it’s wearing.”

“You’re right, it’s wearing, everything is wearing.”

We left together. People still stared at Cass on the streets. She was a beautiful woman, perhaps more beautiful than ever. We made it to my place and I opened a bottle of wine and we talked. With Cass and I, it always came easy. She talked a while and I would listen and then i would talk. Our conversation simply went along without strain. We seemed to discover secrets together. When we discovered a good one Cass would laugh that laugh- only the way she could. It was like joy out of fire. Through the talking we kissed and moved closer together. We became quite heated and decided to go to bed. It was then that Cass took off her high -necked dress and I saw it- the ugly jagged scar across her throat. It was large and thick.

“God damn you, woman,” I said from the bed, “god damn you, what have you done?

“I tried it with a broken bottle one night. Don’t you like me any more? Am I still beautiful?”

I pulled her down on the bed and kissed her. She pushed away and laughed, “Some men pay me ten and I undress and they don’t want to do it. I keep the ten. It’s very funny.”

“Yes,” I said, “I can’t stop laughing… Cass, bitch, I love you…stop destroying yourself; you’re the most alive woman I’ve ever met.”

We kissed again. Cass was crying without sound. I could feel the tears. The long black hair lay beside me like a flag of death. We enjoined and made slow and somber and wonderful love. In the morning Cass was up making breakfast. She seemed quite calm and happy. She was singing. I stayed in bed and enjoyed her happiness. Finally she came over and shook me,

“Up, bastard! Throw some cold water on your face and pecker and come enjoy the feast!”

I drove her to the beach that day. It was a weekday and not yet summer so things were splendidly deserted. Beach bums in rags slept on the lawns above the sand. Others sat on stone benches sharing a lone bottle. The gulls whirled about, mindless yet distracted. Old ladies in their 70’s and 80’s sat on the benches and discussed selling real estate left behind by husbands long ago killed by the pace and stupidity of survival. For it all, there was peace in the air and we walked about and stretched on the lawns and didn’t say much. It simply felt good being together. I bought a couple of sandwiches, some chips and drinks and we sat on the sand eating. Then I held Cass and we slept together about an hour. It was somehow better than lovemaking. There was flowing together without tension. When we awakened we drove back to my place and I cooked a dinner. After dinner I suggested to Cass that we shack together. She waited a long time, looking at me, then she slowly said, “No.” I drove her back to the bar, bought her a drink and walked out. I found a job as a parker in a factory the next day and the rest of the week went to working. I was too tired to get about much but that Friday night I did get to the West End Bar. I sat and waited for Cass. Hours went by . After I was fairly drunk the bartender said to me, “I’m sorry about your girlfriend.”

“What is it?” I asked.

“I’m sorry, didn’t you know?”

“No.”

“Suicide. She was buried yesterday.”

“Buried?” I asked. It seemed as though she would walk through the doorway at any moment. How could she be gone?

“Her sisters buried her.”

“A suicide? Mind telling me how?”

“She cut her throat.”

“I see. Give me another drink.”

I drank until closing time. Cass was the most beautiful of 5 sisters, the most beautiful in town. I managed to drive to my place and I kept thinking, I should have insisted she stay with me instead of accepting that “no.” Everything about her had indicated that she had cared. I simply had been too offhand about it, lazy, too unconcerned. I deserved my death and hers. I was a dog. No, why blame the dogs? I got up and found a bottle of wine and drank from it heavily. Cass the most beautiful girl in town was dead at 20. Outside somebody honked their automobile horn. They were very loud and persistent. I sat the bottle down and screamed out: “GOD DAMN YOU, YOU SON OF A BITCH ,SHUT UP!” The night kept coming and there was nothing I could do.

“When Kip called them, they walked out of the kitchen and onto the terrace, whose border, with its low stone balustrade, was ringed with light.

“It looked to Caravaggio like a string of small electric candles found in dusty churches, and he thought the sapper had gone too far in removing them from a chapel, even for Hana’s birthday.  Hana walked slowly forward with her hands over her face.  There was no wind.  Her legs and thighs moved through the skirt of her frock as if it were thin water.  Her tennis shoes silent on the stone.

“‘I kept finding dead shells wherever I was digging,’ the sapper said.

“They still didn’t understand.  Caravaggio bent over the flutter of lights.  They were snail shells filled with oil.  He looked along the row of them; there must have been about forty.

“‘Forty-five,’ Kip said, ‘the years so far of this century.  Where I come from, we celebrate the age as well as ourselves.’

“Hana moved alongside them, her hands in her pockets now, the way Kip loved to see her walk.  So relaxed, as if she had put her arms away for the night, now in simple armless movement.

“Caravaggio was diverted by the startling presence of three bottles of red wine on the table.  He walked over and read the labels and shook his head, amazed.  He knew the sapper wouldn’t drink any of it.  All three had already been opened.  Kip must have picked his way through some etiquette book in the library.  Then he saw the corn and the meat and the potatoes.  Hana slid her arm into Kip’s and came with him to the table.

“They ate and drank, the unexpected thickness of the wine like meat on their tongues.  They were soon turning silly in their toasts to the sapper –– ‘the great forager’ –– and to the English patient.  They toasted each other, Kip joining in with his beaker of water.  This was when he began to talk about himself.  Caravaggio pressing him on, not always listening, sometimes standing up and walking around the table, pacing and pacing with pleasure at all this.  He wanted these two married, longed to force them verbally towards it, but they seemed to have their own strange rules about their relationship.  What was he doing in this role.  He sat down again.  Now and then he noticed the death of a light.  The snail shells held only so much oil.  Kip would rise and refill them with pink paraffin.

“‘We must keep them lit till midnight.'”

~Michael Ondaatje, The English Patient